They added a seafood section controlled by Buoy One. The prepared food was awful and cold.
Place got off to a rocky start when Waldbaums left and key food took it over, but the place had been fully renovated. Good selection of cheeses, beer, big deli and prepared foods section, some local produce available...seafood section is operated by buoy one and apparently same menu available. Giving this place a second chance and liking it.
The environment in this store is toxic, the employees are rude and mean for the most part and they treat eachother horribly. This afternoon I came to the store and as I was checking out I saw one of the employees leave crying out the door because he was getting picked on by the other employees. I have never seen something so rude and appalling I dont know what they are doing to fix this issue but this is something that didnt go unnoticed and I am shocked that they would allow for their employees to treat eachother this way.
It's disgusting, there is always rotted produce, meats and dairy products on the shelves. If you check the expiration dates you will find lots of things days to weeks passed the expiration date. More than half of their products are overpriced. As for the employees you will hear every reson why thier life sucks in the few minutes it takes to check out. Very disappointing supermarket I won't be back.
I'm updating my review since they renovated and giving four stars. I live on the North fork and have my loyal and nostalgic connections to IGA and King kullen, but I have to admit this is easily the nicest looking market on the North fork now. The store is very well lighted, cashier aisles are wide and approachable, there's a nice salad bar, an appealing produce section, all aisles are labeled, and lots of prepared food options. You can order menu items from the seafood section which is run by the buoy one restaurant but I can't comment on the quality as I have not yet tried it. I think they're still missing a public bathroom, and I'm not crazy about how most of their sales require you to buy multiple items, i.e. 3 for 7 but you must buy three... I also like how I don't find myself walking into employees stocking the shelves constantly.
9 months ago ⭐⭐
They have a few items that king kullen and iga don't have, but it's been months since they took over waldbaums and the majority of their aisles are still not labeled. There are some very nice employees there, and some that seem ridiculously unhappy to be there. I've also noticed a number of items past expiration in the dairy section.
Mattituck Marketplace is a US Grocery Or Supermarket based in Mattituck, New York. Mattituck Marketplace is located at 10095 Main Rd, Mattituck, NY 11952, USA.
Please contact with Mattituck Marketplace using information above: Address, Phone number, Fax, Postal code, Website address, E-mail, Facebook. Find Mattituck Marketplace opening hours and driving directions or map. Find real customer reviews and ratings or write your own review.